| School, Production | Cast Member | Part Played | Special Awards |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aliso Niguel High School, Oklahoma | Camryn Graves | Laurey | Best Dancer Female |
| Anaheim High School, King & I | Alexia Rosa | Anna | Best Dramatic Actress |
| Anaheim High School, King & I | Oliver Rodriguez | Lun Tha | Best Dancer Male |
| Carlsbad High School, Cinderella | Alison Pateros | Charlotte | Best Comedienne |
| El Dorado High School, Children of Eden | Xander Pietenpol | Father | Best Dramatic Actor |
| Huntington Beach APA, City of Angels | Adrian Villegas | Stone | Best Actor |
| La Habra High School, Beauty and the Beast | Bryce Satterfield | Gaston | Best Comedian |
| La Habra High School, Pajama Game | Patrick Gray | Vernon Hines | Best Supporting Actor |
| La Habra High School, Pajama Game | Emily Taylor | Gladys Hotchkiss | Best Supporting Actress |
| Orange Lutheran High School, Shrek | Amanda Dayhoff | Fiona | Best Actress |
| Santa Margarita Catholic High School, Guys and Dolls | Alec Melosini | Sky Masterson | Best Vocal Male |
| St. Margarets Episcopal School, The Secret Garden | Katherine Parrish | Lillie Craven | Best Vocal Female |
* Best Actor and Best Actress will represent MACY Awards at the National High School Musical Theatre Awards in NYC!